[Yoko] Fish- Silent Cruise 的「抄襲」問題

看板YK作者 (火星上的人類學家)時間15年前 (2009/12/05 04:28), 編輯推噓7(7011)
留言18則, 5人參與, 最新討論串1/1
關於這首曲子與Craig Armstrong的關係 我在 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mOM8w4TutVE
看到一個說法如下 the songs are a little similar, but the tempos are completely different, as are the number of number of sound layers, not to mention the fact that master armstrong's sound is based on balance rather than harmony, its actually one of his defining traits . Also being a huge fan of Craig Armstrong, I can tell you that this song indeed did not come out after Ruthless Gravity, but actually almost a year before; S.A.C. is from early 2002 and ruthless gravity was released december 2002... 如果這是真的,那根本沒有抄襲的可能性。 -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 61.216.150.119

12/05 07:13, , 1F
我始終認為一直以來喊YK抄襲的人大多是雞蛋裡挑骨頭
12/05 07:13, 1F

12/05 07:14, , 2F
因為有些樂種終究有曲式的限定,所以才得以簡單分類
12/05 07:14, 2F

12/05 07:15, , 3F
之前抓抄襲很多都是無病呻吟 隨便找個洞就想硬鑽.....
12/05 07:15, 3F

12/05 13:42, , 4F
同樓上。基本上許多爵士樂的編制與曲式真的就是那樣......
12/05 13:42, 4F

12/05 13:42, , 5F
我比較在意的是cyber bird與ride on technology,連動機都
12/05 13:42, 5F

12/05 13:43, , 6F
幾乎一模一樣,連我自己都無法說服自己......
12/05 13:43, 6F

12/05 13:44, , 7F
fish ~ silent cruise的樂念相差非常多,我也覺不是抄襲。
12/05 13:44, 7F

12/05 18:25, , 8F
我補充說明一下好了
12/05 18:25, 8F

12/05 18:26, , 9F
在CB(cowboy bebop)的訪談中,菅野也提到渡邊導演會舉例
12/05 18:26, 9F

12/05 18:27, , 10F
說想用什麼樣的爵士樂,所以說抄襲就太過了(就以CB的部份
12/05 18:27, 10F

12/05 18:27, , 11F
那只是菅野去做出類似的曲風,但是已經被消化過
12/05 18:27, 11F

12/05 18:28, , 12F
如果要說很像,但是風格上來說菅野的爵士並沒有像
12/05 18:28, 12F

12/05 18:29, , 13F
真正的爵士樂那樣的狂野 粗曠這樣的感覺
12/05 18:29, 13F

12/05 18:49, , 14F
而且據說CB許多專輯的內頁曾註明某些曲子是改編自其他作品
12/05 18:49, 14F

12/05 18:49, , 15F
,例如mushroom hunting。
12/05 18:49, 15F

12/05 22:55, , 16F
請看上篇文章XD
12/05 22:55, 16F

12/05 23:19, , 17F
12/05 23:19, 17F

12/08 13:22, , 18F
我可以說貝阿朵出場音樂是抄襲巴哈的嗎
12/08 13:22, 18F
文章代碼(AID): #1B6N3Ic8 (YK)
文章代碼(AID): #1B6N3Ic8 (YK)