[心得] 11集小感
終於到了最期待的老皮的末日演說
看完後第一個感覺是..
勉強及格吧 = =
先從缺點說起吧:
1. 絕望感的營造
絕望感一直都是巨人的賣點,但是這次整段看下來我並沒有從士兵們的態度中體會到
前面幾集的那種強度。小女孩的父親那段轉變得太過迅速了,幾個畫面帶過去我甚至來不
及感受到他的掙扎 orz。 這集補強了很多額外的對話,難到不能夠分個幾秒給士兵們嗎
? 我相信如果多給一個鏡頭先take到老兵的臉 多給個幾秒,在take到士兵們相繼轉身
重回戰場(不要用一張靜畫帶過,這樣會給觀眾一種所有人瞬間都深明大義的不協調感),
戲劇張力會強上10倍才對,這種"無言的留白"沒有做出來讓觀眾感受到,個人認為是十分
可惜的。
2. 老皮的渲染力不足
講到這大概會有人要跟我戰聲優,但是我還是想把我最真實的想法打上來。現實中要
在大聲說話的情況下兼顧到聲調的抑揚頓挫是有難度的,但是也並不是完全作不到。但是
這段演講我從頭到尾聽完我想我應該可以用"大聲而平淡"來形容,沒辦法激發眾人的危機
感來壓過恐懼感。考量到現在這是動畫的情況,聲優將演出重點放在音量而非語氣,是很
失敗的。音量不足我可以腦補假定下方的士兵耳朵靈敏,一點小矛盾無傷大雅,但是語氣
不夠激昂卻造成整段劇情說服力不足,這問題就嚴重了 orz。如果製作組讓聲優加強語氣
表現,而在後製的時候將音量放大,明明可以完美解決的.... (扼腕
打著打著心中的殘念感怎麼越來越強呢...
漫畫中老皮那句"請各位務必! 務必就在這! 在這裡死去吧!"讓我心中的震撼久久不
能平復,但是看動畫我第一個感想是 "阿?就這樣說完了?"
阿阿阿阿阿~~~~
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 114.25.34.93
推
06/16 20:33, , 1F
06/16 20:33, 1F
推
06/16 20:34, , 2F
06/16 20:34, 2F
→
06/16 20:34, , 3F
06/16 20:34, 3F
推
06/16 20:34, , 4F
06/16 20:34, 4F
→
06/16 20:35, , 5F
06/16 20:35, 5F
→
06/16 20:35, , 6F
06/16 20:35, 6F
→
06/16 20:36, , 7F
06/16 20:36, 7F
→
06/16 20:36, , 8F
06/16 20:36, 8F
→
06/16 20:37, , 9F
06/16 20:37, 9F
推
06/16 20:38, , 10F
06/16 20:38, 10F
推
06/16 20:40, , 11F
06/16 20:40, 11F
推
06/16 20:50, , 12F
06/16 20:50, 12F
→
06/16 20:52, , 13F
06/16 20:52, 13F
推
06/16 20:56, , 14F
06/16 20:56, 14F
推
06/16 20:59, , 15F
06/16 20:59, 15F
推
06/16 21:04, , 16F
06/16 21:04, 16F
推
06/16 21:06, , 17F
06/16 21:06, 17F
→
06/16 21:07, , 18F
06/16 21:07, 18F
→
06/16 21:07, , 19F
06/16 21:07, 19F
→
06/16 21:10, , 20F
06/16 21:10, 20F
→
06/16 21:11, , 21F
06/16 21:11, 21F
推
06/16 21:14, , 22F
06/16 21:14, 22F
推
06/16 21:14, , 23F
06/16 21:14, 23F
推
06/16 21:20, , 24F
06/16 21:20, 24F
→
06/16 21:23, , 25F
06/16 21:23, 25F
→
06/16 21:23, , 26F
06/16 21:23, 26F
推
06/16 21:32, , 27F
06/16 21:32, 27F
推
06/16 21:33, , 28F
06/16 21:33, 28F
推
06/16 21:35, , 29F
06/16 21:35, 29F
推
06/16 21:43, , 30F
06/16 21:43, 30F
推
06/16 22:28, , 31F
06/16 22:28, 31F
→
06/16 22:28, , 32F
06/16 22:28, 32F
→
06/16 22:29, , 33F
06/16 22:29, 33F
→
06/16 22:30, , 34F
06/16 22:30, 34F
推
06/16 22:41, , 35F
06/16 22:41, 35F
→
06/16 22:43, , 36F
06/16 22:43, 36F
推
06/16 22:46, , 37F
06/16 22:46, 37F
→
06/16 22:50, , 38F
06/16 22:50, 38F
推
06/16 23:00, , 39F
06/16 23:00, 39F
→
06/16 23:00, , 40F
06/16 23:00, 40F
推
06/16 23:04, , 41F
06/16 23:04, 41F
→
06/16 23:04, , 42F
06/16 23:04, 42F
→
06/16 23:04, , 43F
06/16 23:04, 43F
→
06/16 23:05, , 44F
06/16 23:05, 44F
推
06/16 23:09, , 45F
06/16 23:09, 45F
→
06/16 23:09, , 46F
06/16 23:09, 46F
→
06/16 23:10, , 47F
06/16 23:10, 47F
推
06/16 23:37, , 48F
06/16 23:37, 48F
→
06/16 23:51, , 49F
06/16 23:51, 49F
推
06/16 23:53, , 50F
06/16 23:53, 50F
推
06/16 23:57, , 51F
06/16 23:57, 51F
推
06/17 00:01, , 52F
06/17 00:01, 52F
推
06/17 02:52, , 53F
06/17 02:52, 53F
推
06/17 10:02, , 54F
06/17 10:02, 54F
→
06/17 10:02, , 55F
06/17 10:02, 55F
→
06/17 10:03, , 56F
06/17 10:03, 56F
→
06/17 10:04, , 57F
06/17 10:04, 57F
→
06/17 10:57, , 58F
06/17 10:57, 58F
→
06/17 10:57, , 59F
06/17 10:57, 59F
推
06/17 11:21, , 60F
06/17 11:21, 60F
推
06/17 11:39, , 61F
06/17 11:39, 61F
→
06/17 11:41, , 62F
06/17 11:41, 62F
→
06/17 11:49, , 63F
06/17 11:49, 63F
推
06/17 12:59, , 64F
06/17 12:59, 64F
→
06/17 12:59, , 65F
06/17 12:59, 65F
→
06/17 13:13, , 66F
06/17 13:13, 66F
推
06/17 19:18, , 67F
06/17 19:18, 67F
推
06/17 22:02, , 68F
06/17 22:02, 68F
推
06/18 02:09, , 69F
06/18 02:09, 69F
→
06/18 02:10, , 70F
06/18 02:10, 70F
推
06/18 04:37, , 71F
06/18 04:37, 71F
→
06/18 04:37, , 72F
06/18 04:37, 72F
推
06/18 10:33, , 73F
06/18 10:33, 73F
推
06/18 12:26, , 74F
06/18 12:26, 74F
推
06/18 13:24, , 75F
06/18 13:24, 75F
Isayama 近期熱門文章
PTT動漫區 即時熱門文章